What This Bill Does
This bill is a House resolution that condemns China for violating U.S. airspace with a surveillance balloon in February 2023. The House expresses concern about China's intelligence collection activities and calls on the Biden administration to brief Congress with detailed information about the incident and plans to prevent future violations.
Who It Affects
The bill directly addresses actions by the Biden administration. It also references the Department of Defense, North American Aerospace Defense Command (a military organization that monitors airspace), the Secretary of Defense, the Secretary of State and Congress.
Key Provisions
- The House condemns China's violation of U.S. sovereignty through the surveillance balloon incident. (Resolved, section 1)
- The House denounces China's false claims about the balloon being a weather balloon that veered off course. (Resolved, section 2)
- The House declares it should be U.S. policy to promptly and decisively prevent foreign aerial surveillance platforms controlled by China from violating U.S. sovereignty. (Resolved, section 3)
- The Biden administration must brief Congress with a complete account of all known Chinese infiltrations of U.S. airspace over the past several years, regardless of what type of aircraft or platform was used. (Resolved, section 4, subsection A)
- The administration must provide a complete timeline of the most recent balloon incident from first detection to when it was shot down. (Resolved, section 4, subsection C)
- The administration must describe what options existed to respond to the threat and when the U.S. military recommended those options to the President. (Resolved, section 4, subsection F)
What Changes
This resolution does not create new laws or requirements. A House resolution expresses the position of the House but does not have the force of law. However, the bill does call on the Biden administration to provide Congress with comprehensive briefings about the balloon incident and future plans to prevent similar violations.
Important Definitions
- Surveillance balloon: A balloon belonging to China used to attempt to spy on strategic sites in the continental United States.
- Demarches: Not specified in bill text.
- Force majeure: Not defined in bill text. The bill quotes China's use of this term to mean events beyond one's control.
H. Res. 104
In the House of Representatives, U. S.,
February 9, 2023.
Whereas, on February 2, 2023, the Department of Defense
publicly announced it was tracking over United States
territory a high-altitude surveillance balloon belonging to
the People’s Republic of China (PRC);
Whereas the Department of Defense has since acknowledged
that North American Aerospace Defense Command
(NORAD) first began tracking the surveillance balloon
on January 28, 2023, prior to its entry into United
States airspace;
Whereas the Secretary of Defense has stated that the balloon
‘‘was being used by the PRC in an attempt to surveil
strategic sites in the continental United States’’;
Whereas the surveillance balloon traveled near sensitive
United States national security facilities, including
Malmstrom Air Force Base in Montana;
Whereas, on February 4, 2023, a United States Air Force
aircraft shot down the surveillance balloon off the coast
of South Carolina;
Whereas the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) intelligence
collection directed against the United States poses a
threat to United States interests and security;
2
•HRES 104 EH
Whereas, while the PRC has a long history of intelligence col-
lection operations against United States national security
entities, reports of its espionage have risen significantly
in recent years;
Whereas the CCP attempted to spread false claims about the
nature and purpose of the surveillance balloon, falsely
claiming it to be a weather balloon that veered off-course
due to ‘‘force majeure’’ events;
Whereas, on February 3, 2023, the Secretary of State post-
poned his planned trip to the PRC and referred to the
balloon incident as an ‘‘irresponsible act and a clear vio-
lation of U.S. sovereignty and international law that un-
dermined the purpose of the trip’’;
Whereas Article I of the Convention on International Civil
Aviation, also known as the Chicago Convention, states
that ‘‘every State has complete and exclusive sovereignty
over the airspace above its territory’’;
Whereas although PRC surveillance balloons have previously
violated United States airspace, this incident differs from
those prior violations due to the length of time the bal-
loon spent over United States territory; and
Whereas it is in the United States national security interest
to deter foreign adversaries from engaging in intelligence
collection and other malign activities within United
States territory and airspace: Now, therefore, be it
Resolved, That the House of Representatives—
(1) condemns the PRC’s brazen violation of United
States sovereignty;
(2) denounces the CCP’s efforts to deceive the
international community through false claims about its
3
•HRES 104 EH
intelligence collection campaigns in violation of United
States sovereignty;
(3) determines that it should be the policy of the
United States to promptly and decisively act to prevent
foreign aerial surveillance platforms, including those di-
rected by or connected to the CCP, from violating
United States sovereignty; and
(4) calls on the Biden administration to continue to
keep Congress apprised by providing comprehensive
briefings on this incident that include—
(A) a complete account of all known infiltra-
tions of the national airspace by the PRC over the
past several years, regardless of platform;
(B) a complete account of similar past inci-
dents of the PRC’s use of surveillance balloons
around the world;
(C) a complete timeline of events for the most
recent infiltration from first detection to the even-
tual shootdown of the balloon;
(D) an assessment of what surveillance data
the PRC was potentially able to collect or transmit,
via the balloon while it was over United States ter-
ritory;
(E) a detailed account of what measures were
taken to mitigate the intelligence collection threat
4
•HRES 104 EH
posed by the balloon, the costs of those measures,
and the impact on the regular operations of the af-
fected installations, platforms, and personnel;
(F) a description of what options were identi-
fied to mitigate the threat, and a description and
timing of the recommendation the U.S. military
made to the President regarding those response op-
tions;
(G) a detailed account of diplomatic commu-
nications between the United States and the PRC
regarding this incident, including any demarches by
Department of State personnel and subsequent re-
sponses by the PRC; and
(H) a detailed description of plans, capabilities,
and methods to deter and defeat intelligence collec-
tion activities conducted by the PRC or other for-
eign adversaries in the national airspace system and
any additional authorities needed from Congress to
ensure detection and defeat of these activities in the
future.
Attest:
Clerk.